
After you submit a clemency petition, how will you know what happens next? Will someone invite you to explain your request? Should you send another application when a new President takes office? What can you do while you wait?
Learning the answers can help you organize your preparation and follow through after filing. In this fifth lesson of our Executive Clemency series, I review additional questions from the Office of the Pardon Attorney’s FAQ. I encourage you to read the answers yourself and consider how they apply to the request you hope to make.
Start with the process that applies to you
You do not need to hire a lawyer to apply for a federal pardon or commutation. The Justice Department makes the forms available to applicants and allows people to ask the Office of the Pardon Attorney for clarification about application questions. The office cannot provide legal advice, but understanding what a question asks can help you give a complete response.
You may also wonder whether you must finish your sentence before requesting a pardon. The DOJ’s current FAQ says the President can pardon a person before conviction or completion of a sentence, and that the office will review appropriate requests using its pardon-after-completion-of-sentence form. The President’s authority and the office’s application procedures serve different purposes. If you choose to submit through that office, read and follow its current instructions.
Some circumstances require additional attention. A D.C. Code conviction goes through the presidential clemency process; the D.C. Clemency Board may provide a recommendation. An older conviction under the Federal Youth Corrections Act may already have been set aside by a court certificate. In that situation, the question may concern correcting the record rather than asking for a pardon. The FAQ explains these circumstances so you can investigate which steps fit your case.
Prepare the information you want considered
The Office of the Pardon Attorney does not hold a hearing on your petition. Its clemency process uses written submissions, although a pardon review may include an FBI background investigation. You should therefore take time to explain your request on the page. A reader needs enough information to understand what you seek, why you seek it, and what supports your explanation.
As you prepare, ask yourself:
What would someone need to understand about my circumstances?
Which documents support the information I want considered?
What have I done since my conviction that I can describe accurately?
Those questions can guide the record you build. If you complete a course, describe what you learned and how you used it. If you contribute to your community, record the work and identify someone who can speak from personal knowledge. Over time, those details give you material to review when deciding what belongs in a petition.
Follow the office’s submission requirements. Its FAQ recommends copies rather than original records and says it cannot accept supporting material on digital media or through file-sharing services. A video, online profile, or shared folder may help you organize your work or communicate with supporters, but prepare the relevant information as written material in an accepted format for your application.
Keep track of a pending request
After filing, keep a complete copy of your submission and save the correspondence you receive. Record your clemency case number when one is assigned. The DOJ’s case locator provides a way to check status.
If your application remains pending, you do not need to submit a new form. You can send updated information by mail or email to USPardon.Attorney@usdoj.gov, including your case number when available. Keep your contact information current so the office can reach you.
A change in presidential administration also does not require a new petition. Unless the office closes the matter administratively or the President resolves it, a pending application can continue into a later administration. Filing during one President’s term does not guarantee a decision before that term ends.
That waiting period gives you time to continue work you can control. You might complete an educational goal, accept new responsibilities, or strengthen a release plan. Record what changes and why it is relevant. A useful update helps a reviewer understand something new about your circumstances or conduct.
Understand publicity and a possible denial
Clemency grants become public records. The DOJ lists recipients and information about their cases, and existing lists of people denied clemency can be released through Freedom of Information Act requests. This does not mean the entire application automatically becomes public. Read the privacy information in the form so you understand how the government may use or disclose what you submit.
A denial may arrive without an explanation. Unless the President publicly provides reasons, the DOJ generally does not supply them. Under the current FAQ, a person denied commutation may reapply 12 months after the denial; a person denied pardon may reapply after 24 months. Use that time to assess what has changed and what a future application could explain more fully.
Choose your next step
Begin by reading the FAQ with your own circumstances in mind. Write down one question you need to resolve, identify the official source that addresses it, and save what you learn with your preparation records. Then choose one action you can complete this week that will help you describe your progress accurately.
Our free resources at PrisonProfessors.org can help you organize that work. You can also bring questions to our free interactive webinar, held Wednesdays at 7 p.m. Eastern. My goal is to help you understand the process well enough to take an active role in your own preparation.