Skip to content
Prison Professors

November 16, 2026

Build the Record for Early Termination of Supervised Release

An artist's easel with a half-finished landscape canvas beside a desk holding a folder of papers and a calendar in a sunlit studio

Victor Grandy left federal prison on May 16, 2019, at age 62, after about 26 years. In 2019, he and the government jointly asked the court to reduce his life sentence under the First Step Act. The court cut his prison term for crimes that included distributing crack cocaine to 360 months, and after credit for good time, that meant time served. He still owed a ten-year term of supervised release.

Over the next several years, he built the kind of record that probation officers hope to see. According to the Ninth Circuit's opinion, he had a stable residence and a job, volunteered at a local food pantry, and complied with every condition of supervision. He apprenticed with a painter, became an artist, and in June 2024 a Los Angeles gallery offered him a solo show. His artwork is now collected internationally, and he has exhibited at group and solo shows across the United States. Yet the conditions of his supervision kept him from traveling freely to his own shows.

In February 2025, he asked the court to end his supervision early. The government opposed the motion, and the district judge denied it. On November 12, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel reversed that decision in United States v. Grandy, No. 25-4491, and sent the case back for further proceedings.

Learn What the Court Decided

The appeals court identified three errors in the decision to keep Mr. Grandy under supervision.

  1. A mandatory minimum term does not lock supervision in place. The district court believed that because federal drug law required a minimum term of supervised release, it could not end the term early. The government conceded on appeal that this was wrong. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(e)(1), a judge may end supervised release at any time after one year if the person's conduct and the interest of justice warrant it. The opinion notes that the Sixth, Seventh, and Eighth Circuits reached the same conclusion.
  2. The judge must use accurate information. The district court cited a 2022 U.S. Sentencing Commission study and said 76.5 percent of drug traffickers were rearrested before their supervision ended. The panel found that the figure came from data about marijuana trafficking alone and that the district court misread even that data. The judge also applied a nine-factor test from a 2010 version of the federal judiciary's guide for probation officers, a test that later guidance replaced.
  3. Success counts in favor of ending supervision. The district court reasoned that because supervision was working, it should continue. The panel called that approach a "Catch-22": "The more they demonstrate their successful reintegration, the less likely they are to obtain early termination of their supervised release."

The ruling does not end Mr. Grandy's supervision. It returns his motion to the district court for a fresh decision. It also binds federal courts only within the Ninth Circuit, which covers California, Arizona, Washington, and several other western states. Still, its reasoning gives anyone on supervised release a clear picture of what a judge should weigh.

Read the Guidance Probation Officers Use

According to the opinion, the current guidance for federal probation officers, found in the 2018 and 2025 versions of the Guide to Judiciary Policy, recommends a presumption in favor of early termination when a person under supervision meets six criteria. Under the 2018 version, as the opinion quotes it, after eighteen months even people classified as higher risk "who have demonstrated a reduction in risk" and who are in substantial compliance "must be considered for early termination."

A probation officer sees your reports, your home, your work, and how you respond when something goes wrong. When the officer supports a request, or at least does not oppose it, the judge has an informed voice telling the court that supervision has done its work.

After my first year of supervised release, an Assistant U.S. Attorney filed the motion to end my supervision. I did not have to ask, and a federal judge granted it. The record I had built in prison, and during that first year home, led her to write the motion. I could not control what the prosecutor or the judge would decide, but I could keep doing work they could see and verify.

Build the Record a Judge Can Review

Mr. Grandy's motion rested on specific facts: where he lived, where he worked, how he served, and how supervision limited a career he had built. Consider what your own record would show.

  • Have you reported on time, answered questions truthfully, and followed every condition in your judgment?
  • What work do you do, and how long have you done it?
  • How are you meeting your responsibilities to family, and to any victims through restitution?
  • Where do you contribute to your community, and who could describe that work?
  • Which condition limits an opportunity you are ready to pursue, and how would ending supervision allow you to pursue it?

Write the answers down with dates, and keep pay stubs, restitution receipts, certificates, letters from employers or volunteer coordinators, and a short monthly journal entry describing what you worked on and what you learned. When you or your lawyer prepares a motion, those records let you explain your progress with examples rather than general statements. Our lesson on requesting early termination of supervised release walks through the statute, timing, and a starting template for a motion.

Prepare Before Supervision Begins

A person still in prison, or still waiting for sentencing, can begin this work today. The habits a judge will later look for—showing up, finishing what you start, telling the truth, and serving others—can be practiced in a housing unit, a classroom, or a work assignment. Think about an orchard: a tree planted this spring will not bear fruit this fall, but the person who plants early has something to harvest later.

Our free Playbook lesson on supervised release explains standard and special conditions and the rules for asking a judge to end supervision. Our lesson on working with probation officers describes what officers expect from the first meeting. A Prison Professors profile gives you a place to organize journal entries, book reports, and a release plan so you can return to your goals and measure progress. A profile does not file anything with the court; you or your lawyer would still select the material and submit it according to the court's rules.

No record guarantees that a judge will end supervision early. Judges weigh the statutory factors case by case, and prosecutors may oppose. Even so, the Ninth Circuit has now said plainly that success on supervision should weigh in a person's favor, not against him.

Choose One Step This Week

Read your judgment and list every condition of your supervision, or the conditions you expect to receive. Then answer one question in a journal entry:

  • If a judge reviewed my record a year from today, what specific work would I want that judge to see?

Pick one action that would add to that record, finish it this week, and set a date to review what you accomplished.

Prison Professors used AI tools to help draft this article. Our team reviewed and edited it for accuracy before publication. It is educational information, not legal advice.

Sources